Paul Bernardo, a.k.a. the Scarborough rapist, plagued a Canadian suburb with a series of horrific rapes that were only the tip of an iceberg.
Paul Bernardo, a.k.a the Scarborough rapist, together with his wife Karla Homolka were a couple of charismatic Canadian killers.
Indeed, before Bernardo was put behind bars for multiple murders, tortures, and rapes, he was a salesman by trade and he lured his female victims using pickups and pitches he learned on his day job. He studied how to entice women like he studied how to do well in business.
He read the classic horror novel American Psycho “like his bible” and when he met and married Karla Homolka, his sadistic streak only increased as she encouraged his behavior. The couple even became known as the “Barbie and Ken” killer couple. In the end, Bernardo was found to responsible for at least 13 rapes and perhaps four killings.
Paul Bernardo’s Early Life
Paul Bernardo was born on Aug. 27, 1964, in Ontario Canada to Kenneth and Marilyn Bernardo. The Bernardos were a “financially well-off,” stable middle-class family. But as with everything else in the story of Paul Bernardo, this deceptively normal exterior masked a dark truth.
In 1975 Kenneth Bernardo was charged with child molestation and there were rumors he had even molested his own daughter. Paul Bernardo did not seem to be unduly affected by this dark turn in his childhood. Observers recall him as being “always happy…a young boy who smiled a lot.”
It wasn’t until he was 16 when his mother revealed to him that he was actually the result of an extramarital affair that Bernardo’s outward behavior began to noticeably change.
He began to refer to his own mother as a “slob” and a “whore.” When he went off to study at the University of Toronto, he became adept at picking women up at bars only to later humiliate and beat them.
Paul Bernardo was good-looking and charming, an unfortunate combination that he used to manipulate women and take them off their guard. Before long, he would give in to a far darker impulse.
Appearance Of Bernardo As The Scarborough Rapist
Starting in May of 1987, the suburb of Scarborough in Ontario was plagued by a series of horrific crimes.
In the early hours of the morning of May 4, 1987, a young woman getting off the bus was grabbed and brutally raped near her parents’ home. Over the next week alone, there would be two more similar assaults.
The women were all between the ages of 15 and 21 and the attacks all included beatings, intense verbal abuse, and dire threats to discourage victims from going to the police, led authorities to conclude that they had all been perpetrated by the same man, whom the newspapers quickly dubbed the “Scarborough Rapist.”
During his nearly five-year rampage as the Scarborough rapist, Paul Bernardo raped or attempted to rape at least 19 young women — and this is only the official count. The victims were all young women often grabbed around bus stops, although at least one 15-year-old was attacked in her own bedroom.
A couple of Bernardo’s victims managed to fight him off and Bernardo was actually questioned by the police twice, but he was never named as an official suspect. It wasn’t until May of 1990 that one of Bernardo’s victims was able to give police an accurate description of her attacker and by then, the Scarborough Rapist had become even more unhinged.
Enter Karla Homolka
Paul Bernardo had met Karla Homolka in 1987 when he was 23 and she just 17.
Homolka was born to Dorothy and Karel Homolka in Ontario in 1970 and was the eldest of three siblings. She was described as a “well adjusted, pretty, smart, and popular” child with a fondness for animals that led her to start working at a veterinary clinic after high school. Like Bernardo, there was nothing in Homolka’s outward appearance that hinted at the depravity lurking just beneath the surface.
Bernardo and Homolka had an immediate attraction, one which only intensified when Bernardo discovered that, unlike the other girls he had dated, Homolka shared the same sick fantasies.
They quickly began a sadomasochistic relationship in which Bernardo acted as an abusive master and Homolka as a willing slave. The whole while they dated, Paul Bernardo was also brutally raping girls in Scarborough with Homolka’s knowledge and approval.
Bernardo and Homolka eventually became engaged. Homolka described to a friend how “Paul and I are happier than ever…he’s being so great, so romantic, but that’s typical of my honey.” But the truth was that three years into their relationship, Paul Bernardo was getting bored. He complained to Homolka that she was not a virgin when they met and soon turned his sick attentions elsewhere: To Homolka’s 15-year-old sister, Tammy.
Far from being outraged at Bernardo’s desires, Homolka once again encouraged them. She told Bernardo that she wanted him to have her little sister’s virginity for a Christmas present.
On Dec. 23, 1990, while at a Christmas party at the Homolka family home, Homolka spiked her own sister’s drinks with animal anesthetics she had stolen from the clinic where she worked. That night while the rest of the family was asleep and Tammy was unconscious, Homolka held a Halothane-soaked cloth over her sister’s mouth and took turns raping her with her fiancee, while videotaping the whole brutal incident.
When Tammy began choking up vomit, the couple panicked and tried to hide the evidence before calling an ambulance. The teenager never regained consciousness and was pronounced dead at the hospital. Although the mysterious chemical burn on her face was noted, the drugs in her system were not detected and her death was ruled an accident as the result of choking on vomit from alcohol poisoning.
The Barbie And Ken Killings
Rather than sate Bernardo’s appetite for blood, the murder of Tammy Lyn Homolka only increased it. In 1991, Homolka lured another teenager she had befriended at work to the home she now shared with Paul Bernardo. The couple again drugged the girl, abused her, and videotaped it, only this time the “Jane Doe” survived and woke up with no memory of the horrific events.
Bernardo and Homolka married on June 29, 1991, the very same day a horrified couple canoeing in Lake Gibson discovered concrete blocks containing human body parts in the water. The remains belonged to 14-year-old Leslie Mahaffy, who had disappeared on June 15. She had been kidnapped by the Barbie and Ken killers and abused over the course of several days. As this grisly discovery was made, the killers enjoyed an elaborate wedding ceremony which included their entrance in a white horse-drawn carriage.
Almost a year later, on April 16, 1992, the couple struck again this time grabbing and killing 15-year-old Kristen French. They left her body battered and her hair partially shaved in a ditch along a rural road.
Police soon realized that the two murders were connected. After the release of a composite sketch that resembled Paul Bernardo, tips were called in, some from coworkers and friends who reported Bernardo’s disturbing penchant for violence.
In January 1993, Homolka left her husband after he dealt her a particularly vicious beating with a flashlight. Within two months, a DNA sample taken from Bernardo turned up as a match for the Scarborough rapist and he was put under surveillance before eventually being arrested in February of 1993.
Aftermath And Incarceration
Realizing the gig was up, Homolka quickly got a lawyer and sought a plea bargain in exchange for testifying against Paul Bernardo. She claimed Bernardo had told her he’d raped at least 30 women. The government agreed to a 12-year sentence in exchange for her cooperation, although this backfired dramatically when the videotapes the couple had made showcasing their gruesome crimes were discovered and Homolka’s true nature was revealed. Karla Homolka was not the abused victim she had attempted to portray herself as but rather a cruel sadist.
Homolka was ultimately released in 2005 and since remarried and given birth. Paul Bernardo was found guilty of all charges against him and consequently sentenced to life for the rape, murder, and kidnap of two teenaged girls, though it is believed he’d killed a couple more. His rape victims number somewhere in the double digits, presumably around 13.
Bernardo’s application for parole in 2018 after 25 years in prison was denied after only 30 minutes of deliberation. A lawyer on behalf of the victims’ families reported that “There’s never been an apology by Paul Bernardo. There’s been never any indication whatsoever of remorse.” Indeed, Bernardo admitted to the court that he hadn’t felt anything for his victims at the time of his sadistic crimes.
Next, read about how some of the other most infamous serial killers finally met their downfalls. Then read the full story of America’s most notorious serial killer, Ted Bundy.